Wednesday, 15 May 2013

ColeopterYUM



Insects as a food source? Why not? We rape and pillage nearly everything else on the planet. Insects are fast growing, have a high fecundity, some are multivoltine, convert feed efficiently, have low space requirements and are possibly delicious. They could be the answer to a sustainable food source for the earths growing population.

I was inspired to delve into the exquisite world of insect cuisine and explore it after watching numerous accounts of a personal hero: Bear Grylls, gorging himself on squirming insects. Bear seems like a man who knows how to keep himself alive, and insects seem to keep him going. The article that I found and interested me into entomophagy (the consumption of insects) was “Nutritional composition and safety aspects of edible insects” by Birgit A. Rumpold and Oliver K. Schlu¨ ter.

 

http://importfood.com/thai_insects.html 

Entomophagy has been a part of life for numerous cultures around the world for thousands of years as insects are regarded as being highly nutritious and full of protein and energy. One study showed that consuming 100g of caterpillar gives you 76% of your daily intake of protein and nearly 100% of your daily intake of vitamins. The energy intake was very similar to that of normal consumable meats.

 From the different orders of insects, the average contents of insects are proteins and fats, followed by fibre, nitrogen-free extract and ash.

As can be seen from figure 1 above, proteins make up the majority of the composition of insects. The average protein contents of insects range from 35.34% for Isoptera to 61.32% for Orthoptera. For 100grams of most mainstream sources of protein around today like meats and beans, insects trump them with a higher protein content. In a trial with rats fed with crickets (orthoptera), and rats fed on soy beans, it was shown that the insects were a better source of amino acids than the soy beans. A similar study was also done on chickens showing similar results.


Fats also make up a high composition of insects. The fatty acids in insects are similar to those found in fish and poultry, and also have low cholesterol contents.

 Research has shown that although insects are low in calcium and potassium, they are good potential sources of micronutrients like copper, iron, magnesium, manganese, phosphorus selenium and zinc. The levels of the micronutrients in edible insects could also be controlled by the type of feed provided for the insects.

 Besides providing just minerals, insects can also be a valuable source of vitamins. It has been shown that 100g of insect dry matter is rich in riboflavin, pantothenic acid and biotin, and also folic acid which are all essential vitamins for humans. Some vitamins like vitamin A, C and niacin were not at efficient levels in 100g of insect dry matter. In contrast to this however, it has been shown that an insect tea contained 15.04mg of vitamin C per 100g. The Food and Agricultural Organisation of America recommend 45mg of vitamin C per day for an adult, so 300mL of insect tea covers this, which is just over the size of a normal cup of tea. Mmmmm… Edible insects can provide important sources of vitamins, although insects do need to be selected for specific vitamins. The vitamin content of insects could also be selected via the insects feed.

Eating insects may not be all fun and games however! Just like other edible plants and animals, caution does need to be applied to the consumption of some insect species. Some insects contain allergens and other toxins which would be detrimental to human health if consumed. An example of this is the African silkworm. It was recently shown that the silkworms contain a heat resistant thiaminase that has been responsible for seasonal ataxic syndrome cases due to a thiamine deficiency in Nigeria over the last 40 years. Insects, like shellfish, can also cause allergic reactions in people when consumed. Like other consumable plants and animals, there is always the risk of food poisoning and poor food preparation causing illness to the consumer. Insects that are harvested from the wild may contain traces of pesticides in them which could be harmful for human health; however this may be rectified by controlled feeding of artificially raised insects.
http://itthing.com/strange-weird-meals-made-with-insects

It can be concluded that edible insects are a potential food source for the earths growing human populations of the coming years. They are high in energy, proteins, and fats and contain valuable minerals and vitamins. A huge advantage of them is that their composition can be manipulated by their feed matter, allowing for an easy way to get much needed substances and minerals into populations of humans in need of them specifically. More research is needed into how to raise and manipulate compositions and also on insect’s storage and preparation for eating. Before this goes too far though, the cultural issue of consuming insects needs to be overcome by today’s fickle minded and squeamish steak and potato eating humanoids.

Thanks for reading my blog guys. The link to the article is below and is well worth a read. It also has a list of all known edible insects’ species in the world, so get out there and start sampling them!

 

http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/mnfr.201200735/abstract;jsessionid=0E8226C75C3F01C10ABB12C3F29397A7.d03t03

 

LAND where you want to be!

 

Nick

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

9 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. (Sorry, I found a spelling mistake I couldn't live with.)

      Delete
  2. This is a great article, and a great viewpoint. I guess my mum was right when she tried to convince me to eat aphid-infested broccoli when I was younger, saying it was 'just extra protein'. It is also probably important to realise that the fickle-minded and squeamish culture, as you put it, that we have is mostly responsible for the heavy pesticide use in agricultural industries. Wouldn't it be great if the use of such chemicals could be reduced through recognition of the fact that insects in vegetables and fruit do not detract from the overall nutritional value of such foods?
    I'm wondering if any research has been done into why we may have evolved to avoid insects in foods - perhaps something to do with disease associations and avoidance?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thats a very nice idea, and im sure with a bit of seasoning (salt, pepper and some T.sauce) i could give entomophagy a go. Touching on the point raised above, is it possible to try and turn the standard cultural view around and start tucking into insects on a daily basis? Should we catch some bugs, fry them up and take them around and let people try them. Personally I like the idea of making a 'bug pie' and seeing if people actually like it, without them realising it's made from bugs and not pork? Better yet, instead of pea, pie and pud what about grasshopper, fly pie, and mashed bees!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think it would be a long and arduous struggle to get people to turn to entomophagy. People who have there eyes open and can see that the world is not far off some major issues like food, water, space and global warming would not be too hard to convince. However those with cotton wool over their eyes that are oblivious to the problems left for us by our ancestors, and which we are also adding too, would be much harder to convince.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Of course, perhaps it is a good thing that people are unlikely to turn to entomophagy. Agreed, there is very little on earth our species does not exploit, and yes, there is a lot of evidence pointing to the fact that we are not far off having some major resource shortages, particularly food. But I think it is dubious logic that suggests we should consider adding yet another resource to the long list of those we deplete. All populations are subject to environmental carrying capacities, and we cannot be an exception. Therefore turning to entomophagy can be seen as really only raising the bar slightly to allow further population growth, and all too soon we will still hit the same problem - it is just delaying the inevitable. The only solution to food shortages in any population that exceeds its carrying capacity is negative population growth or extinction - and the further a population increases above the carrying capacity, the greater the fall.

    I still maintain though that the article is a good one - and it's always fun to challenge the way we think.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As crop pests have such a detrimental impact, would it not make sense to harvest these pests and utilise them if possible? It would possibily increase the production of the crops and product a by-product. Certainly if done in a methodical and sustainable manner, insects that are safe to eat could be exported or given to 3rd world countries in Africa. The ethical issue probably only occurs in developed countries, where as these places live on a cup of rice a week!

      How's that for abit of 'food for thought'?

      Delete
    2. Certainly I agree with you that this would potentially address the problem of food shortages, but I maintain that this would do nothing to address the underlying problem of which food shortages are merely a symptom, which is overpopulation.

      Delete
  6. Very interesting article Nick! In my Agro-ecology class (ECOL 309) we looked into entomophagy as a way of feeding the world too. Here is an article we covered in class from the NZ herald; it claims eating insects is good for you and good for the world.
    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/lifestyle/news/article.cfm?c_id=6&objectid=10883543
    Currently I am not too keen on the idea of eating insects but as taught in ECOL 309 we are the world, so we must feed the world -United Nations says we must double food production by 2050 to feed the population, so entomophagy could be a great option. I am definitely open to the idea of eating insects (I think like most people once you get over the fact that it is an insect it will be fine)- who knows it could one day be my favourite food. In my flat we live off wild pork, venison, duck etc maybe I could show the boys up with their hunting skills and go and gather some nutritious insects (using my collection techniques from ECOL 304) next time its my turn to cook!!

    ReplyDelete